Ecolex Logo
The gateway to
environmental law
Search results » Jurisprudence

Public Prosecutor vs Ministry of the Environment. Preventive Action

Country/Territory
Uruguay
Type of court
National - higher court
Date
Feb 25, 2009
Source
UNEP, InforMEA
Court name
Tribunal de Apelaciones en lo Civil de 6ºTº
Seat of court
Montevideo
Judge
Dra. Selva Anabella KLETT FERNANDEZ, Dr. Felipe Javier HOUNIE SANCHEZ, Dra. Elena MARTINEZ ROSSO
Reference number
20/2009
Language
Spanish
Subject
Waste & hazardous substances, Land & soil, Legal questions
Abstract

A case concerning lead pollutions of the soil and of the water in the neighbourhood of Montevideo called “la Teja”.

 

The public prosecutor sued the State and the ministry of the Environment for not taking the necessary actions to protect the environment and the local populations and mitigate the pollution. As a result, several residents of la Teja are suffering from lead poisoning.

The public prosecutor required the State and the Environmental Ministry to take, within a six months delay, measures to relocate the victims and to neutralize the sources of the lead pollution.

 

But the court considered that the Administration could not be held responsible because the pollution was resulting from a third person. It also concluded that the Administration had reacted adequately as it created an inter-institutional commission to investigate, required technical assistance from Brasil and the USA, proceeded to various inspections and published several protocols on soil and study on conservation. Therefore, The court considered that the Environmental Administration did everything within its power and therefore could not be held accountable for negligence. Thus, the court dismissed the appeal of the public prosecutor.

Full text
SENTENCIA Nº 20 2009.pdf
hojaInsumo2.seam