Ecolex Logo
The gateway to
environmental law
Search results » Jurisprudence

People of Weloy ex rel. Pong v. M/V CEC Ace

Country/Territory
Micronesia, Fed. States
Type of court
National - higher court
Date
Jun 29, 2007
Source
UNEP, InforMEA
Court name
Supreme Court
Judge
Yamase, D.K.
Reference number
15 FSM Intrm. 151
Language
English
Subject
Environment gen., Food & nutrition, Legal questions, Sea
Keyword
Marine pollution Traditional rights/customary rights Marine pollution (dumping at sea) Standing to sue Marine pollution (ship-based sources) Liability/compensation Access-to-justice
Abstract
The defendant vessel grounded on the reef. The plaintiffs named 3 chiefs to maintain the action as a class action and alleged 6 causes action: maritime negligence, infliction of emotional distress, unseaworthiness of the vessel, trespass, nuisance (public and private) and punitive damages. There were 2 classes of plaintiffs- all residents of the affected community and those who owned the natural resources by tradition. The plaintiffs filed a motion for Class Certification. Only the class of plaintiffs who had traditional rights to the resources were considered for certification because they were the only class that was represented by a named plaintiff of that class. The court found the requisite commonality to the class where the common questions as to liability predominated over individual questions. The court did not include the emotional distress claim because the complaint did not allege that the class as a whole suffered a common physical injury. The certification was conditional upon the court receiving more information of the potential number of affected residents to confirm the numerosity requirement; and the court also required further evidence that the named plaintiffs were adequate class representatives especially in light of the fact that only one class of plaintiffs was considered for certification.
Full text
COU-159865.pdf