Ecolex Logo
The gateway to
environmental law
Search results » Jurisprudence

Committee of Reflection, Information and Anti-Nuclear Fight

Country/Territory
France
Type of court
National - higher court
Date
Aug 4, 2006
Source
UNEP, InforMEA
Court name
Conseil d'Etat
Seat of court
Paris
Judge
MARTIN
Reference number
254948
Language
French
Subject
Waste & hazardous substances
Abstract

The Conseil d’Etat is asked to cancel the decree n°2003-30 of 10 January 2003 authorizing the national agency for the management of radioactive wastes (ANDRA) to modify the situation of a radioactive waste disposal site to a monitoring phase.

The claimant argued that the decree violated certain obligations of the Convention for the Protection of the Marine environment of the North-East Atlantic, and the precautionary approach and the principle of prevention.

The European Community is a party to the Convention for the Protection of the Marine environment of the North-East Atlantic since the decision of 7 October 1997. The provisions of articles 2-1 a) and 3 of the Convention include precise obligations and do not require any supplementary measures. They are consequently directly applicable in the national country. It judged that the decree complied with the Convention for the Protection of the Marine environment of the North-East Atlantic.

The Court stated that the principle of prevention of risks to the environment (article L.110-1 of Environmental Code) can be invoked against a decree adopted in the framework of the measures taken by the national agency for the management of Radioactive Waste to modify a radioactive waste disposal site. However the judge has a limited control on the measures taken according to this decree in order to comply with the prevention principle.  It ruled that the decree did not breach the precautionary approach and the principle of prevention.

Full text
Conseil_d_État_10ème_et_9ème_sous-sections_réunies_04_08_2006_254948_Publié_au_recueil_Lebon.pdf