Ecolex Logo
The gateway to
environmental law
Search results » Jurisprudence

Action of unconstitutionality against the decreet N3216 of the 21st/10/2009

Country/Territory
Paraguay
Type of court
National - higher court
Date
Dec 28, 2010
Source
UNEP, InforMEA
Court name
Supreme Court
Seat of court
Asunción
Judge
V. M. Nuñez Rodriguez. M. O. Bajac Albertini, S. Blanco
Reference number
No. 1787
Language
Spanish
Subject
Environment gen.
Keyword
Resource/damage valuation Management/conservation
Abstract

The Supreme Court is asked to review the constitutionality of Decree No. 3,216 whereby the use of sodium tripolyphosphate in detergents is prohibited.

The Decree states that according to studies by the SEAM, the content of phosphorus in powder detergents as sodium tripolyphosphate, generates damage to the environment and quality of life of human beings.

Applicants argues that with regards to the fact that it applies to imported and sold detergent products containing Sodium tripolyphosphate, the decree issued by the Government is contrary to constitutional rules relating to environmental, taxation, and freedom. Moreover, they assert that the government exceeded its powers and functions, as it is not authorized to prohibit the use of a substance in the production, importation or marketing of detergents, or creating new taxes.

The court followed the reasoning of the applicants, understanding that the government cannot legislate through decrees, so in this case, the government took powers from the legislative power, violating the principle of the division of powers enshrined in Article 3 of the Constitution.

Full text
ACCIÓN DE INCONSTITUCIONALIDAD Nº 1787.pdf