Ecolex Logo
The gateway to
environmental law
Search results » Jurisprudence

6,226 ciudadanos contra el Poder Ejecutivo

Country/Territory
Peru
Type of court
National - higher court
Date
Jul 26, 2011
Source
UNEP, InforMEA
Court name
Tribunal constitucional
Judge
MESÍA RAMÍREZ
ÁLVAREZ MIRANDA
VERGARA GOTELLI
BEAUMONT CALLIRGOS
CALLE HAYEN
ETO CRUZ
URVIOLA HANI
Reference number
EXP. No 00024-2009-PI
Subject
Legal questions, Agricultural & rural development
Keyword
Indigenous peoples Agricultural development Agriculture and environment Agricultural commodities Agricultural land
Abstract

The Peruvian Constitutional Tribunal is asked to review the constitutionality of the legislative decree No 994 which promotes private investments in irrigation projects to improve agricultural capacities through the irrigation of “unproductive” lands.

Opponents of the legislative decree argue that it violates the rights for indigenes to be consulted and informed in accordance with the convention 169 of the International Labour Organisation on indigenous and tribal peoples and the UN Declaration of the rights of indigenous people. Indeed, this legislative decree only applies to lands without property titles and therefore to lands belonging to indigenous communities as most of them do not have any property titles on their lands.

The court considered that the legislative decree No 994 was in line with the constitution and with convention 169 of the ILO because it does not apply to indigenous territory. Indeed, the court pointed out that the decree applies only to “unproductive lands” with agricultural suitability belonging to the State.